The City of St. Louis is asking a panel of federal judges to reconsider a January decision to allow a lawsuit against city police officers to go to trial.
Short of that, the city is asking for a rehearing in front of the entire U.S. District Court of Appeals for the Eighth District to stop the case from moving forward, according to the filed Thursday.
On Jan. 25, a three-judge panel in the Eighth District a lower court鈥檚 decision that qualified immunity 鈥� or protection of officers from lawsuits 鈥� didn鈥檛 apply in the arrest of retired U.S. Air Force Lt. Col. Brian Baude in a 2017 St. Louis protest.
鈥淧olice may be entitled to qualified immunity protections if they arrest individual offenders with at least arguable probable cause,鈥� it states, 鈥渂ut officers cannot enjoy such protections by alleging that 鈥榯he unlawful acts of a small group鈥� justify the arrest of the mass.鈥�
St. Louis City Counselor Sheena Hamilton argues in her petition that the court should reconsider the case because 鈥渢he panel opinion raises questions of national importance in the context of policing mass civil disorder.鈥�
Attorney Javad Khazaeli, who represents Baude, said the city鈥檚 argument regarding qualified immunity, if successful, would have repercussions nationwide.
鈥淭hey鈥檙e asking for the Eighth Circuit to issue an order to tell everybody in the nation that there is an expansion of qualified immunity when police officers beat people when it鈥檚 during a protest,鈥� he said. 鈥淩emember the Eighth Circuit doesn鈥檛 just rule over St. Louis. Any decision that they make will be binding over all of the George Floyd protests of Minnesota.鈥�
Khazaeli said it鈥檚 his understanding that the city plans on appealing to the U.S. Supreme Court if unsuccessful with the appeals court.
A spokesman for the city declined comment, citing pending litigation.
On Sept. 17, 2017, Baude walked out of his home in downtown St. Louis to investigate any potential destruction during a protest, where people were decrying the acquittal of former St. Louis police officer Jason Stockley in the 2011 killing of Anthony Lamar Smith.
That evening, Baude got swept up in a mass 鈥渒ettling鈥� arrest of more than 100 people, where officers surrounded everyone within an intersection on all sides. Video evidence shows, appellate judges wrote in their January opinion, a 鈥済enerally peaceful and compliant crowd.鈥�
And the mass arrest not only involved, 鈥渁 few people noisily proclaiming their constitutional right to assemble, but others who were generally gawking and milling about, others on bikes riding through the area, some people sitting on the street and on the sidewalk, and even a person pushing a baby in a stroller,鈥� the judges wrote.
Baude鈥檚 lawsuit is among that are being represented by the law firm. The individuals 鈥� who include downtown residents, independent journalists, Washington University students and members of the military 鈥� claim they were wrongfully beaten, pepper-sprayed and arrested.
The city鈥檚 petition states that, 鈥渢he panel opinion sets a dangerous precedent for police attempting to preserve public order in civil disorder situations.鈥�
Hamilton was appointed by Mayor Tishaura Jones, who has largely been supported by the movement for racial equity and police accountability. She campaigned that on the idea that her administration would address police brutality cases differently than previous mayors.
Upon Hamilton鈥檚 appointment, the mayor鈥檚 chief of staff Jared Boyd told the new city counselor is going to be 鈥済iven a mandate to reconsider what winning looks like,鈥� and not only trying to prevent a financial loss for the city on such cases.
鈥淚t鈥檚 not to say we shouldn鈥檛 be cognizant of city resources,鈥� he said, 鈥渂ut that can鈥檛 be the only thing.鈥�
is part of States Newsroom, a network of news outlets supported by grants and a coalition of donors as a 501c(3) public charity. Missouri Independent maintains editorial independence.
